I`m giving it 5 stars because I really like the quality of the fabric and the cut of the top, it looks really pretty knotted at the back and I also like it worn knotted or open at the front. One small point of criticism is that the black version in the product photos definitely has long sleeves - and a hood too! As I really like hoods, I opted for the black top. It came without a hood and the sleeves are half-length, just like the other colors. But as I still really like the top, I will keep it - highly recommended :-)